Proven laser engraving and cutting since 1988 — Golden, Colorado Request a Free Quote

Cutting Steel on the xTool S1: Which Jobs Actually Work (And Which Ones Waste Your Money)

Why I'm Not Giving You One Answer

I've made thirteen documented mistakes with laser equipment since 2019. The most expensive: assuming a 40W diode laser could handle any steel job if I ran it slow enough. That assumption cost me $420 in ruined 3mm plate and roughly 11 hours of production time in September 2022.

Here's what I've learned since: whether the xTool S1 40W diode laser can handle steel laser cutting depends entirely on the type of steel work you're doing. There's no universal yes or no. So let me split this into the four scenarios I've actually encountered. Find yours and skip the rest.

(A necessary caveat: my numbers come from the 40W module. The 10W and 20W versions have different limits, and I haven't tested them as thoroughly. Your settings will also differ from mine—test first.)

Scenario A: Thin Sheet Metal (Under 1mm)

This is where the 40W module actually pulls its weight. Cold-rolled steel or stainless at 0.5mm to 1mm, with air assist at full pressure—I run nitrogen on stainless, compressed air on mild steel—you can get a clean through-cut in four to six passes.

My first real success was a batch of custom stencils from 0.8mm stainless back in March 2023. It took five test attempts to dial in the settings. I burned through about $85 in test material before landing on 1,400mm/min, 85% power, six passes, air assist at 25 PSI. Your numbers will vary—alloy composition matters a lot more than people admit.

One thing I wish someone had told me: you need a proper honeycomb bed underneath, or you'll scorch the surface below the workpiece. I learned that one on a $200 birch plywood sheet I was using as a backing board. Not my finest afternoon. Oh, and make sure the bed itself is rated for metal work—the cheap ones warp under repeated heat.

Scenario B: The 1-3mm Trap

Here's where I need to push back on something I see repeated online. People assume if a 40W module cuts 1mm, then 3mm is just "more passes." It doesn't scale that way. The physics don't cooperate.

In November 2022, I quoted a client order—forty small brackets from 2.5mm mild steel—as a three-hour job. It took nine hours. The edges had visible dross—actually, "visible" is putting it kindly. They looked like someone had chewed the metal into shape. The kerf width varied by almost 0.3mm across the run, and $280 of material went straight to scrap because the cuts weren't clean enough for the client's tolerance.

The "just buy more power" thinking comes from an era when 5W and 10W modules were standard. That's changed now that 40W modules exist. But more wattage doesn't remove the underlying limitation—it just moves the wall further out. Cutting 2mm steel is technically possible. Building a production workflow around it is not.

Can the S1 get through 2mm? Yes, slowly. Should you price a job assuming it will? Absolutely not.

Scenario C: Structural Steel (3mm+) — Wrong Tool

If you're regularly cutting 3mm or thicker steel, you don't need a laser and engraving machine. You need a plasma cutter—that's a tool that uses an electrically conductive gas (usually compressed air) to create a plasma arc hot enough to melt through metal. Completely different approach, different operating cost, different safety profile.

I've seen people try pushing the S1 into this range with 20+ passes and specialty gases. Two problems: your diode gets hammered, and the cut quality never matches even a cheap plasma cutter.

Honestly, I'm not sure how much a regular diet of thick steel shortens diode lifespan. My best guess based on other shop owners' reports is that it's significant, but I don't have hard data. What I do know: a replacement module costs more than paying a local shop to plasma-cut your steel.

Scenario D: Non-Metal — Where the S1 Earns Its Keep

Here's the part that matters most for B2B work, and it's the part steel-cutting conversations skip. The xTool S1 was built as a multi-material machine. Wood, acrylic, leather, glass, coated metal for engraving—that's the core use case. Steel is a stretch goal, not the main event.

A client sent back a side-by-side of two acrylic signage samples: one from their budget setup, one from my S1. Their words: "The second one looks like it belongs in a showroom." That's the quality perception argument in a nutshell. When your output looks sharp, clients assume your whole operation is sharp. When it looks rough, they assume the rest is rough too—whether that's fair or not.

The xTool S1 laser specs support the pitch: 40W output, 498×319mm work area, swappable module system. I keep a 20W module around for fine detail on leather and paper—smaller kerf, cleaner edges.

One warning on the multi-material workflow: swapping modules takes about four minutes, but you also need to re-level the bed and re-check focus. I once ran a batch of engraved leather after a steel job and forgot to reset the air assist. Ruined three $40 hides—$120 mistake, all because I skipped a line on my own checklist.

How to Know Which Scenario You're In

Ask three questions:

  1. What's the thickest metal you cut in a typical month? Under 1mm: Scenario A. 1-3mm occasionally: Scenario B. 3mm+ regularly: Scenario C territory.
  2. What's your volume? A one-off prototype on 2mm steel might be worth trying. Fifty units a month? You'll lose money on labor and consumables.
  3. What's the deliverable? Engraving on coated metal: solid yes. Through-cutting thick steel: no. Mixed non-metal production: the S1's sweet spot.

The Checklist I Wish I'd Had in 2022

Before buying an xTool S1 for a steel-cutting project, run through this:

  • Test the exact alloy and thickness first. Buy a sample. Spec sheets and YouTube videos are starting points, not answers.
  • Price the alternative. A local fab shop with a plasma cutter will often beat your in-house laser time on anything over 1.5mm.
  • Factor in module wear. Every pass on steel is harder on the diode than wood or acrylic.
  • Confirm your air assist setup. Compressed air handles wood. Steel wants more pressure—and sometimes nitrogen for clean edges.

(Last note: this reflects my testing through Q4 2024 with the 40W module and the firmware version available at that time. Specs and third-party options change; verify before committing to a production workflow.)

Nobody hands you a checklist on day one. I built mine after about $1,200 in mistakes. Yours can start with the four items above—and maybe save you the $420 I lost on 3mm plate back in 2022.

Share this article:
Jane Smith

Jane Smith

I’m Jane Smith, a senior content writer with over 15 years of experience in the packaging and printing industry. I specialize in writing about the latest trends, technologies, and best practices in packaging design, sustainability, and printing techniques. My goal is to help businesses understand complex printing processes and design solutions that enhance both product packaging and brand visibility.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked